New Wealthify customers: £80 cashback via TopCashback, £50 cashback via Quidco and only £25 each via my referral link. When the reduction was announced, Nick Hungerford, CEO of Nutmeg, said: “We are crushing these barriers to entry and are dedicated to making to quality investing available to everyone. We It keeps costs down by mainly focussing on passive investments, such as Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) and tracker funds that don’t incur additional fund manager costs. That’s why Nutmeg shows such large changes in pounds – they are generated from a much bigger amount of money. Legal & General is a big financial services company which offers insurance, lifetime mortgage, pensions and stocks and shares ISAs. Hi – I just came across this and wanted to suggest you might want to update your screengrabs for Nutmeg. Here are the screen grabs from my accounts, showing how they’ve done over two years. We may also receive compensation if you click on certain links posted on our site. I’m Faith, and I’m passionate about helping people make the most of their money. Wealthify did also manage to make back the 2018 losses with a great year in 2019 where they performed slightly better than Nutmeg in their Tentative and Confident funds and even showed a solid advantage on Wealthsimple in their Tentative fund. Nutmeg has 10 different portfolios ranging from “cautious” to “aggressive”, while Wealthify offers five, from “cautious” to “adventurous”. Capital at risk. Our goal is to create the best possible product, and your thoughts, ideas and suggestions play a major role in helping us identify opportunities to improve. Back in 2018,  I was frustrated by the lack of performance figures from this new breed of investment websites. VWRL's 5 year annualised performance is 12.52%. Nutmeg doesn’t charge any flat fees. I went for the highest risk ‘Adventurous’ options for Moola and Wealthify and level 9 of 10 for Nutmeg. The only unclear part is the allocation to ISAs which is perhaps too clever (or cautious) - all available ISA investment it utilized from all the pots. Confirm details with the provider you're interested in before making a decision. ; Wealthify is backed by Aviva, which should give some confidence to seasoned investors. Nutmeg® is a registered trade mark of Nutmeg Saving and Investment Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, no. Wealthify response to FCA. – coronavirus hit. Up until 2019, Wealthify used to have different rates for accounts with different deposit amounts. So rounding out an eventful second year, I still wish Nutmeg had done better. Then Wealthify and Nutmeg match that profile to investment strategies that use algorithmic trading models to enter into trades in the market. It doesn’t offer cashback bribes. Depending on the package you choose, Nutmeg will let you pay as little as 0.25% in fees each year. Investment platforms are popping up all over the place, allowing everyone to try out investing, no matter how much experience or knowledge of the subject they have. Death of moneybox vs Nutmeg after Fidelity and Schwab cut their fees to zero following Robinhood pioneering platform. Disclosure: No-one has paid me to write this post, although I have written collaborative posts with Vanguard in the past. Not suited for trading shares. That just means it shows how much the investments actually grew, regardless of any cash added or withdrawn, in my case the cashback and referral bonus from Wealthify, and the cashback and extra £100 a month paid into Nutmeg. Currently my investments have very similar proportions of equities (aka shares in companies, the risky bit that drives growth but can also fall furthest): 80% for Vanguard, 81% for Nutmeg and 83% for Wealthify. Nutmeg vs Wealthify – Costs. Nutmeg has slashed minimum investments and now offers a Junior Isa. So could be a great time to pick up more for your money – although brace yourself for a rocky road ahead! Investing has recently become a popular venture. Capital at risk. In this feature, compare the performance of their investment … When you compare the Nutmeg's managed portfolio to the other two robo-advisors (Wealthify and Moneyfarm both do a certain amount of managing) it gets a bit muddled, but Moneyfarm is the winner. There’s no questionnaire to guide your choice. Moneybox vs. Nutmeg Nutmeg is highly-rated by our community of reviewers, who have praised it for ease of use, flawless design and first-rate customer service. Vanguard offers low-cost investments directly to UK investors. Hey, great post, I’m looking to start using Vanguard from reading your blog and many others, but thinking is this the best time to start as fund\share prices should be lower now? They're far simpler than normal investing but you're tied to a 'portfolio' of funds. Nutmeg received strong Boring Money tester scores for novices, as well as good customer ranking for their website. Minimum investment. That’s a better deal than using my referral link, where I get £100 but you only get 6 months without Nutmeg fees. I’m intending to publish a new post showing three year performance, fingers crossed it’s better than March 2020… Nutmeg vs Moneyfarm: Advice & Learning Resources Both Nutmeg and Moneyfarm are committed to helping new users learn about how to make the most of their money. However, sometimes these robo-funds offer cashback via a special link when you invest, which'll get you a head start over other funds. If you’re planning to save your money into a fixed rate bond, we take a look at how you can find the best 2 year option. Do share in the comments, I’d love to hear! that aims to provide you with the tools you need to make better Capital at risk. In practice, for that range of equities, ARC’s Equity Risk portfolios were down on average between -7% and -14.1% in the two years to 21 March 2020. And of course, Fidelity just followed suit. Nutmeg's highest performing risk "10" portfolio has a 6.5%5 year annualised performance. Nutmeg. The investing options are clear and well described. interactive investor is a flat-fee platform, which makes it cost effective for larger portfolios. investment growth,  £1,000 contribution, Nutmeg: -£619 & -15.12% investment growth, £3,600 contributions & cashback, Wealthify: -£91.37 & -8.48% investment growth, £1,100 contributions & cashback. In 2011, Nutmeg became the … Thankfully, I’m investing for a good 10 years. It's got three different retirement options. I need to look at my own figures a little more carefully, so I’m not going to comment on them just yet. So I bunged £1,000 into three different robo advisers, Nutmeg, Wealthify and Moola, to see what happened. Moola has already shut up shop. How do these robo adviser results compare to other wealth managers? But back in December 2019, they changed things to a standard flat 0.6% fee across all account types. I checked my other accounts at the same time, which was pretty much the peak of the market. Wealthify invests in a range of assets including shares, cash, corporate bonds, Government bonds, and commodities. I love the theory of robo advisers, offering slick websites and managing your money for relatively low fees. Wealthify vs MoneyFarm vs Nutmeg performance. However, pleased with their constant communication throughout the past 5weeks and rebalancing of my account. Example cliff, for my investments to fall off. In the meantime, I can confirm that Wealthsimple medium risk SRI portfolio returned 9.35%, Wealthsimple medium risk portfolio returned 3.27%, Nutmeg portfolio 5 - SRI returned 6.5% and Nutmeg portfolio 5 returned 3.6%. I included the combined headline loss to highlight the very real risks of investing in the stockmarket. We have built our own portfolios from ETFs in the past, and done a pretty good job too – but investing consistently into multiple ETFs can still be problematic on a traditional platform due to transaction fees. Now – over to you. Invest from as little as £250 with the Wealthify Investment ISA. Suggest any comparison should stick with the time-weighted returns (ie the percentages), which strip out the affect of any withdrawals or subsequent contributions. With Wealthify, you have 24-hour, year-round online access to your investments. Compare this to the losses of Nutmeg’s riskiest portfolio and you’d have been better off with Wealthify. For those living in the UK or Italy, Moneyfarm is one of the top UK robo advisers to consider partnering with. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again:  get investment decisions wrong,  and any cashback could be eaten up in poor performance and expensive charges. 1. We may receive compensation from our partners for placement of their products or services. Capital at risk. However, the Nutmeg product offers much more flexibility. Hi Ramon – You said it, March and April were definitely volatile! Just one look at their websites will tell you that they both have stacks of guides and options for you to read up and research how everything is likely to work. Nutmeg vs Moneyfarm: Advice & Learning Resources Both Nutmeg and Moneyfarm are committed to helping new users learn about how to make the most of their money. Their ETF trading might be a bit higher, but when you average out the fees, they are a bit cheaper than Wealthify and clearly cheaper than Nutmeg's managed offering. However, sometimes these robo-funds offer cashback via a special link when you invest, which'll get you a head start over other funds. Nutmeg vs Wealthify: costs Nutmeg charges based on how much you invest. Nutmeg has a few more options available, such as the LISA. Capital at risk. Have you dared check your balance recently? Wealthify also has its own code of practice, set out in our ethical investing policy. Tick ‘I have daily data’ if you want to compare specific dates rather than months. our site. So my question is whether it is worth to invest in wealthify initially and then move to Vanguard if I don't find a similar offer, or should I go straight to Lifestrategy and make my monthly payments there? Data Protection ICO registration number: Back then, I was looking at investment growth with Vanguard of £203 (20%),  with Wealthify of £187 (18%) and with Nutmeg, from the bigger investment, of £368 (13.5%). By the end of the first year, I’d invested £5,200 across four different companies, including the £100 a month payments to Nutmeg. Manage your money with an easy-to-use Moneybox app. Nutmeg® is a registered trade mark of Nutmeg Saving and Investment Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, no. If it helps, my balances today (9 June 2020) are: Vanguard: £1,159.12 on £1,000 invested, so all time growth of £159.12 and 15.91%, and up £63.75 and 5.82% over the last year, Wealthify: £1,231.25 on £1,100 invested and cash back, so all time growth of £131.25 and 11.72%, and up £70.59 and 5.58% over the last year. They're far simpler than normal investing but you're tied to a 'portfolio' of funds. When it comes to choosing an online investment company, Hargreaves Lansdown, TD Direct Investing, and Nutmeg Investment are all prime choices among today’s robo advisers in the UK. decisions. If you do want to choose between investment websites, bear in mind that this comparison is only over two years, which is a really short time when investing. The only reason my Wealthify balance wasn’t less than I’d paid in was because the losses hadn’t entirely eaten away my original £50 cashback and a more recent £50 refer-a-friend bonus. With Moneyfarm, you’ll be charged 0.75% on the first £10,000 A pretty close approximation of that would be a passive global index tracker, such as Vanguard's VWRL ETF. The £200 Nutmeg cashback was credited in May 2019 (thank you) and my £100-a-month direct debits continued. Compare platforms similar to Nutmeg and Wealthify, Data indicated here is updated I stuck with them after March and they have bounced right back! I posted the results of my investments after a year, when everything in the garden was rosy. Zoe has a BA in English literature and several years of experience in writing about all things personal finance. [Collaborative post]. Meanwhile Nutmeg grew less than half as much as Vanguard originally, and over two years has fallen nearly three times further: -5.41% for Vanguard and -15.12% for Nutmeg. You can transfer the cash value from the Vanguard one into Nutmeg if you wanted. Completely right that I only continued with regular payments with Nutmeg, after the initial lump sum investments in all three.